This page lists Appeals Lodged against Council Planning, Enforcement and High Hedge Decisions only since 2015.
If you would like to find out about any appeals earlier than this please contact the planning department direct at planning@scilly.gov.uk for advice.
2025
1. P/24/084/HH & P/24/085/LBC: Treskey, The Garrison, St Mary's, Isles Of Scilly, TR21 0LS REFUSED
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/W/25/3364460 & APP/Z0835/Y/25/3364459
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Dismissed, Decision Upheld
Inspector: S Edwards
Appeal Decision: Appeal Decision
2. P/25/027/S106MO: Prospect Lodge, Well Lane, St Mary's, Isles of Scilly, TR21 0HZ
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/Q/25/3366170
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Dismissed, Decision Upheld
Inspector: S Edwards
Appeal Decision: Appeal Decision
2024
1. P/24/073/S106MO: Prospect Lodge, Well Lane, St Mary's, Isles of Scilly, TR21 0HZ REFUSED
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/Q/24/3354987
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Dismissed, Decision Upheld
Inspector: C Parker
2023
1. P/22/081/HH Westward Ledge, Church Road, St Mary's Isles of Scilly REFUSED
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/D/23/3322177
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Allowed, Decision Overturned
Inspector: T Gethin
2022
1. P/21/054/HH Westward Ledge, Church Road, St Mary's Isles of Scilly REFUSED
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/D/22/3290086
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Dismissed, Decision Upheld
Inspector: H Nicholls
2. P/22/009/COU Appletree, 2 Matthews Field, Church Road, St Mary's, Isles of Scilly REFUSED
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/W/22/3301914
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representations
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Dismissed, Decision Upheld
Inspector: T Gethin
2021
1. P/20/045/COU Land at Lawrence's Brow, Churchtown, St Martin's Isles of Scilly REFUSED
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/W/21/3287898
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Informal Hearing
Hearing Date: 28th June 2022, 10am, Virtual with public permitted to watch in the Old Wesleyan Chapel
Site Visit Date: 29th June 2022, 11am at the site.
Inspector: H Nicholls
Costs Application: Yes - Costs Refused.
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Allowed, Decision Overturned.
2020
No Appeals
2019
1. P/18/090/FUL Land to the rear of Men-a-Vaur, Church Road, St Mary's isles of Scilly REFUSED
Appeal Ref: APP/A0835/W/19/3225058
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Dismissed, Decision Upheld
2018
No Appeals
2017
Appeal Ref: APP/HH/1677
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Dismissed, Decision Upheld
2. E-17-003 Enforcement Notice against land to the rear of The Ropewalk, Porthloo, St Mary's Isles of Scilly - Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/C/17/3172304
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED:
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Dismissed, Enforcement Notice Upheld
3. P/16/060/FUL Land at Holy Vale Farmhouse, Holy Vale, St Mary's Isles of Scilly REFUSED
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/C/15/3006441
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Allowed, Decision Overturned
2016
1. P/16/084/FUL Land at White Cottage, Porthloo, St Mary's Isles of Scilly REFUSED
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/W/16/3166073
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Allowed, Decision Overturned
2015
1. P/15/025/FUL Buccabu, Lower Strand, St Mary's Isles of Scilly REFUSED
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/W/15/3134610
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Dismissed, Decision Upheld
Appeal Ref: APP/Z0835/C/15/3006441
APPEAL STATUS: DETERMINED
Appeal Type: Written Representation
Appeal Outcome: Appeal Allowed, Enforcement Notice quashed